Best Teething Toys 2026: Pain Relief & Safe Chewing AU

Best Teething Toys Australia 2026: Pain Relief & Safe Chewing

Last updated: March 2026

Choosing the best teething toys Australia 2026 means understanding safe materials, effective pain relief, and what actually survives baby’s determined chewing. With prices from $5 (Kmart) to $40 (Sophie la Girafe), knowing what works prevents wasting money on unused teethers while helping your miserable baby find relief.

This comprehensive guide compares the top teething toys Australian parents trust in 2026, all non-toxic and designed for aggressive chewing.

Quick answer: Matchstick Monkey ($15-25) offers best pain relief with innovative design reaching back molars. Budget winner: Kmart Silicone Teethers ($5-8) are safe, effective, and cheap enough to have multiples. Cult favorite: Sophie la Girafe ($30-40) remains popular despite price (but not necessary!).

—

When Do Babies Start Teething?

Typical timeline:
0-3 months:

• ❌ Too early for teething (despite drool!)
• Drooling normal at this age
• Hands in mouth = exploration, not necessarily teeth

4-7 months:

• ✅ Most common teething start
• Bottom front teeth (central incisors) usually first
• Signs: drooling, chewing everything, irritability
• Some babies no teeth until 12+ months (normal!)

8-12 months:

• Top front teeth emerge
• Side incisors appear
• More intense chewing need

12-24 months:

• First molars (PAINFUL – big flat teeth)
• Canines (pointy teeth)
• Peak teething discomfort

24-36 months:

• Second molars (last baby teeth)
• Final teething stage
• Most painful for many toddlers

Total: 20 baby teeth by age 2-3
Important: Every baby different! Some early (3 months), some late (12+ months). Both normal.

—

Teething Symptoms (What’s Normal)

Definite Teething Signs:

• ✅ Excessive drooling
• ✅ Chewing on everything (hands, toys, furniture!)
• ✅ Red, swollen gums
• ✅ Irritability/fussiness
• ✅ Disturbed sleep
• ✅ Pulling ears (back teeth causing ear discomfort)
• ✅ Rejecting food (sore gums)

NOT Caused by Teething:

• ❌ High fever (>38°C) – see doctor
• ❌ Diarrhea – different issue
• ❌ Vomiting – not teething
• ❌ Rashes (except drool rash on chin)

If baby has fever/vomiting/diarrhea: See doctor. Don’t blame teething for serious symptoms.

—

What Makes a Good Teething Toy?

✅ Must-Haves:

1. Food-Grade Safe Materials

• Silicone (medical/food-grade)
• Natural rubber (without chemicals)
• Untreated wood (beech, maple)
• BPA-free, PVC-free, Phthalate-free

—

2. Right Texture

• Varied surfaces (bumps, ridges, smooth)
• Firm enough for pressure
• Not so hard baby can’t bite
• Multiple chewing points

—

3. Easy to Grip

• Small enough for baby hands
• Lightweight
• Easy to hold at different angles
• Won’t slip when wet (and it WILL be wet!)

—

4. Reaches Back Teeth

• Long enough to reach molars
• Design encourages deep chewing
• Not just front teeth relief

—

5. Easy to Clean

• Dishwasher safe OR
• Boilable OR
• Easy hand-wash
• No hollow parts (mold risk)

—

❌ Avoid:

• Liquid-filled teethers (can leak, bacteria growth)
• Amber teething necklaces (choking/strangulation risk – NOT recommended)
• Frozen teethers (too hard, can damage gums)
• Small parts (choking hazard)
• Painted toys (paint chips off when chewed)

—

Top Teething Toys Australia 2026

1. Matchstick Monkey ($15-25) ⭐ BEST OVERALL

View on Amazon

Innovative design wins:
Reaches back molars:

• Genius: Long “arms” reach back teeth
• Most teethers only help front teeth
• Back molars = most painful teething
• Design encourages deep chewing

Textured for relief:

• Bumpy surfaces on arms
• Varied textures (smooth + ridges)
• Firm enough for good pressure
• Soft enough not to hurt gums

Practical features:

• Easy-grip body
• Lightweight
• Dishwasher safe
• BPA-free, food-grade silicone
• Cute monkey design (parents love it too!)
• Clip attachment available

Why parents choose it:

• Actually works for molar pain (rare!)
• Baby can hold independently
• Stays entertaining (not boring solid teether)
• Worth the $20

Limitations:

• More expensive than basic teethers
• Some babies ignore the arms (chew body instead)
• Not freezer-safe

Worth it if:

• Baby has molar pain (12+ months especially)
• Want effective back teeth relief
• Appreciate thoughtful design
• Budget allows $20 teether

Where to buy:

• Amazon AU: $18-22
• Baby Bunting: $22-25
• Pharmacies: $23-26

Parent review: “Only teether my daughter used during molar hell. The long arms genuinely help back teeth. Wish I’d found it sooner!” – Sarah, Melbourne

—

2. Kmart Silicone Teethers ($5-8) ⭐ BEST BUDGET

Incredible value:
Cheap but safe:

• Food-grade silicone
• BPA-free, non-toxic
• Multiple shapes (ring, keys, animal)
• Textured surfaces

Good enough:

• Does the job
• Baby can grip easily
• Dishwasher safe
• Multiple colors

Why buy cheap:

• Teethers get lost/dropped constantly
• Have 5-10 around house, car, nappy bag
• Don’t cry when dropped in public toilet
• $5 vs $30 – function similar!

What you sacrifice vs premium:

• Less innovative design
• Basic shapes
• Shorter lifespan (6-12 months vs years)
• Not as cute

Perfect for:

• Having multiple backups
• Daycare (won’t be devastated if lost)
• Travel (disposable if needed)
• Budget-conscious families

Worth it if:

• Want quantity over brand names
• Practical approach (it’s getting chewed, not displayed!)
• Save money for things that matter more

Where to buy:

• Kmart: $5-8

Parent review: “Bought 8 for $40. Always a teether within reach. Same silicone as expensive ones.” – Kate, Brisbane

—

3. Sophie la Girafe ($30-40) ⭐ CULT FAVORITE

View on Amazon

Controversial but beloved:
Why people buy it:

• Iconic: Most famous teether globally
• Natural rubber (from hévéa tree sap)
• Squeaks (baby entertains self)
• Soft texture
• Lightweight, easy to grip
• Gift-worthy (fancy packaging)

Natural materials:

• 100% natural rubber
• Food-grade paint
• No plastics
• Eco-friendly

The controversy:

• Price: $35-40 for a teether?!
• Does it work better than $5 Kmart? Debatable.
• Mold concerns (hollow inside, can’t clean thoroughly)
• Purely natural = some babies allergic to latex

Honest assessment:

• Works fine, but so do cheaper options
• You’re paying for brand/design/gift appeal
• Not necessary, but nice to have
• Some babies obsessed with it, others ignore it

Worth it if:

• Want “designer” baby product
• Appreciate natural materials
• Gift for someone else (popular shower gift)
• Budget allows splurge

NOT worth it if:

• Tight budget (Kmart works just as well)
• Practical over pretty
• Worried about mold (valid concern!)

Where to buy:

• Baby Bunting: $35-40
• David Jones: $38-42
• Amazon AU: $32-38

Parent review: “Gorgeous gift, baby loves it. But honestly, she chews the $6 Kmart one just as much.” – Emma, Sydney

—

4. Nuby Silicone Teethe-eez ($10-15) ⭐ BEST MULTI-TEXTURE

View on Amazon

Variety of sensations:
Multiple surfaces:

• Soft bristles (gum massage)
• Smooth surfaces
• Bumpy nubs
• Ridged areas
• Baby chooses what feels best

Textured for exploration:

• Different textures = different relief
• Bristles massage inflamed gums
• Firm parts for pressure
• Soft parts for gentle comfort

Practical design:

• Easy-grip handles
• Lightweight
• Bright colors (easy to find when dropped)
• Dishwasher safe
• BPA-free

Popular styles:

• Keys (multiple textures on each “key”)
• Banana (weird but beloved!)
• Ice-cream cone
• Octopus

Limitations:

• Some hollow parts (potential mold – clean carefully)
• Bristles can trap food (rinse immediately after use)
• Not as durable as solid silicone

Worth it if:

• Want variety for baby
• Like multi-textured options
• Middle-ground price ($10-15)
• Baby responds to stimulation

Where to buy:

• Woolworths/Coles: $12-15
• Chemist Warehouse: $10-13
• Amazon AU: $10-14

—

5. Jellystone Designs Teether ($15-22) ⭐ BEST AUSTRALIAN BRAND

Aussie-made quality:
Australian design:

• Made in Australia
• Food-grade silicone
• Unique designs (rainbow, llama, flower)
• GOTS certified organic cotton (some range)

Sensory features:

• Textured surfaces
• Crinkle fabric (some styles)
• Wooden elements (natural beech)
• Multi-sensory stimulation

Quality construction:

• Durable (lasts multiple children)
• Easy to clean
• Dishwasher safe
• Non-toxic materials certified

Aesthetic appeal:

• Beautiful designs (not garish)
• Instagram-worthy (if you care!)
• Gift-quality presentation
• Modern color palettes

Limitations:

• More expensive ($15-22)
• Harder to find (not in Kmart/Big W)
• Some babies prefer plain over decorative

Worth it if:

• Support Australian businesses
• Want quality that lasts
• Appreciate design aesthetics
• Gift for style-conscious friend

Where to buy:

• Jellystone Designs website
• Baby Bunting (some range)
• Independent baby boutiques

—

Features Comparison Table

—

Natural Teething Remedies (Besides Toys)

Safe & Effective:

1. Cold washcloth:

• Wet clean cloth
• Freeze for 30 minutes (not solid frozen)
• Baby chews on cold fabric
• Free and works!

2. Chilled cucumber/carrot:

• Large piece (no choking risk)
• Refrigerated (not frozen)
• Supervision required
• Soothing + nutritious

3. Frozen breast milk popsicles:

• Breast milk in ice mold
• Use mesh feeder
• Cold + nutrition + comfort
• Genius multi-tasker

4. Gum massage:

• Clean finger
• Gentle pressure on gums
• Circular massage
• Soothing for some babies

5. Pain relief gel (if needed):

• SM-33 (Australian brand)
• Apply sparingly
• Follow label directions
• Short-term use only

—

Avoid (Unsafe):

• Amber necklaces – strangulation/choking risk (Red Nose advises against)
• Frozen teethers – too hard, can damage gums
• Topical anesthetics with benzocaine – dangerous for babies
• Alcohol on gums – never!
• Homeopathic tablets – not proven effective, potential risks

—

Cleaning & Hygiene

Daily Cleaning:

After each use:

• Rinse under running water
• Wash with hot soapy water
• Use bottle brush for textured areas
• Rinse thoroughly
• Air dry completely

Dishwasher (if safe):

• Top rack only
• Check manufacturer guidelines
• Still inspect for residue after
• Air dry completely before storage

—

Weekly Sterilizing:

Boiling method:

• 5 minutes boiling water
• Check if teether is boil-safe first!
• Especially if dropped on floor outside
• Or if baby has been sick

Steam sterilizer:

• Follow device instructions
• Convenient if you have one for bottles
• Kills 99.9% bacteria

—

Mold Prevention:

Critical:

• Ensure completely dry before storage
• No hollow spaces (mold grows inside)
• Check for discoloration
• Smell test (musty = mold)
• Discard if any mold suspected

Sophie la Girafe specific:

• Hollow inside (can’t clean thoroughly)
• Never submerge fully
• Wipe exterior only
• Replace if mold suspected

—

Common Teething Myths Debunked

Myth 1: “Teething causes fever”

Truth: Teething may cause slight temperature rise (<38°C), but NOT actual fever. High fever = infection, see doctor.

—

Myth 2: “Amber necklaces help”

Truth: No scientific evidence. Choking/strangulation risk. Red Nose Safe Sleep strongly advises against.

—

Myth 3: “Every baby needs Sophie la Girafe”

Truth: Marketing hype. $5 silicone teether works just as well for most babies. Sophie is luxury, not necessity.

—

Myth 4: “Frozen teethers best for pain”

Truth: Hard frozen items can damage tender gums. Cold yes (refrigerated), frozen solid no.

—

Myth 5: “Teething causes diarrhea”

Truth: Coincidence. Babies start solids around teething age = digestive changes. Actual diarrhea needs doctor.

—

Budget Breakdown

Budget Setup: $15-30

• Kmart silicone teethers × 4: $24
• Cold washcloth: $0 (already have)
• Total: $24 (multiple backups)

Mid-Range: $40-60

• Matchstick Monkey: $22
• Nuby multi-texture: $12
• Kmart backups × 3: $18
• Total: $52

Premium: $80-100

• Sophie la Girafe: $38
• Matchstick Monkey: $22
• Jellystone Designs: $20
• Kmart backups × 3: $18
• Total: $98

Reality: Most babies have favorites (unpredictable which!). Start budget, add if needed.

—

Age-by-Age Teething Toy Guide

4-7 Months: First Teeth (Front)

Best: Simple ring teethers, easy-grip
Recommend: Kmart silicone ring, Nuby multi-texture
Why: Front teeth only, basic chewing needs

—

8-12 Months: More Teeth

Best: Varied textures, different sensations
Recommend: Nuby, Matchstick Monkey (for practice)
Why: Exploring different relief options

—

12-18 Months: First Molars (PAIN!)

Best: Reaches back teeth
Recommend: Matchstick Monkey (essential now!)
Why: Back molar pain = need specific relief

—

18-24 Months: Canines

Best: Multi-textured, durable
Recommend: Matchstick Monkey, Jellystone
Why: Varied pain points, intense chewing

—

24+ Months: Second Molars (Last!)

Best: Durable, reaches back
Recommend: Matchstick Monkey, frozen washcloths
Why: Final teething stage, most painful for many

—

FAQ

Q: When do babies start teething?

A: Typically 4-7 months for first tooth, but anywhere from 3-12 months is normal. Some babies born with teeth!

Q: What’s the best teething toy?

A: Matchstick Monkey for back teeth, Kmart silicone for budget/basics, Nuby for variety. Every baby different!

Q: Are amber necklaces safe?

A: No. Red Nose Safe Sleep advises against due to choking/strangulation risk. No scientific evidence they work.

Q: Can I freeze teething toys?

A: Refrigerate yes (cold), freeze solid no (too hard, damages gums). Cold washcloth better than frozen teether.

Q: How do I clean teething toys?

A: Hot soapy water after each use. Dishwasher top rack if safe. Boil weekly for sterilizing (check if boil-safe).

Q: My baby refuses all teethers, what do I do?

A: Try cold washcloth, chilled cucumber, gum massage. Some babies prefer natural methods over toys.

Q: Is Sophie la Girafe worth $40?

A: Luxury item, not necessary. Works fine but so do $5 teethers. Worth it if you want premium gift/natural rubber.

Q: How long does teething last?

A: From first tooth (~6 months) to last molar (~2-3 years). Not constant pain – comes in waves as teeth emerge.

—

Related Guides

Baby Care:

• Best Baby Products Australia 2026
• Baby Registry Must-Haves
• Best Baby Moisturizer

Feeding:

• Best Sippy Cups Australia
• Best Bottles for Breastfed Babies

Gifts:

• Useful Baby Gifts Australia
• Newborn Gift Ideas

—

Teething toys provide relief, not miracles. Most babies do fine with basic silicone teethers (Kmart $5-8). Matchstick Monkey worth it for molar pain (12+ months). Avoid amber necklaces (unsafe). Cold washcloths and cuddles often work as well as expensive toys. 🦷

\n\n

Related Guides

\n

\n
• Baby Products Guide

\n

• Baby Registry

\n